Home
Features
Departments
News & Trends
|
Patient
Care
10 Ways to
Communicate Better with Patients
From personal
satisfaction to better patient outcomes, there are lots of good reasons to
improve your communication skills.
Judith
Lee, Contributing
Editor As you struggle with declining
reimbursements and feel pressured to see more patients, theres little
time to acknowledgemuch less improvedoctor-patient communication.
Yet medical experts around the country urge
physicians to take a step back and consider the importance of every patient
interaction they have.
Ive discovered along the way that how effectively one
communicates has a lot to do with patient outcomes, says William D.
Clark, MD, an internist in Bath, Maine, who is associated with the American
Academy on Physician and Patient, which is dedicated to improving doctors
communication skills. Yet the advances in medicine and the incredible
amount of information we have to share with patients make it harder and harder
to focus on true communication.
Research supports Dr. Clarks
experience. Numerous studies point to benefits of communication, ranging from
increased patient satisfaction and compliance to a reduced incidence of
malpractice litigation. And medical experts believe todays rushed
environment is harming doctors as well as patients.
Communication with patients
is the heart of medicine. It is the history that provides 70 percent of the
diagnosis, says Allan Platt, PA-C, an instructor at Emory University and
collaborator on a communication instructor kit used by 40 medical schools and
physician assistant programs. Besides, communication is the
fun part of medicine. Physicians would feel more rewarded knowing
they had better interactions. The gratitude from the patients is
priceless.
Oakland, Calif. ophthalmologist Richard Lee, MD, learned this
first-hand in his relationship with an elderly patient, who had once been his
kindergarten teacher.
This lady would call me about every two weeks to talk about
her eyes, but that wasnt really what was on her mind, Dr. Lee says.
She had terminal cancer, and she was alone in the world. I always took
her calls, no matter what I was doing. What I found was that she didnt
need a lot of my timejust a few minutes. What she mainly needed was just
a small amount of undivided attention. When I found out she had passed away, I
felt so good that Id been able to give her that.
Communication experts note that busy
ophthalmologists may not be able to find extra time, but they can
improve the quality of the time they already spend with patients.
Physicians are taught to cure more than to care, says Larry
Mauksch, M.Ed., a family counselor and clinical associate professor at the
University of Washington Medical School. As such, they are more
interested in doing something. This means they are prone to talk
rather than listen, advise rather than inquire and prescribe rather than
empower. While many physicians complain about lack of time, research suggests
that how we use time is more important than how much time we have.
Here are some tips
from the experts that may help you.
- Stop Talking. Research indicates
that physicians, in their rush to communicate, talk too much to patients. In
one study, the physician interrupted 69 percent of patient interviews within
the first 18 seconds. In 77 percent of these interviews, the patients
reason for coming to the physician was not fully elicited.
Doctors talk too much because theres so much to talk
about, says Dr. Clark. But patients are not medical students. They
dont need all the facts. Some people need simple answers, and others just
need comfort.
Listen. In the same study noted above, when the
patient was allowed to speak without interruption, he or she spoke for more
than two minutes. This is your opportunity to do what patients most need you to
do.
Patients are a lot more satisfied if they can talk more,
rather than less. You must listen carefully to learn the true needs of the
patient, Dr. Clark advises.
- Look at the patient. Too many
times, physicians are either writing in the chart or looking at it as they
speak to the patient. Experts say you should always sit down and maintain eye
contact with the patient. I always sit directly across from the patient,
and make eye-to-eye contact. This helps to slow things down, so the patient
doesnt feel rushed, says Dr. Lee.
- Get to know the patient. Many
times, patients have been trained by physicians to wait to be
questioned. Invite the patient to speak by asking some leading questions. If
you havent met the patient before, allow a few moments to learn something
about the patient, by saying, I like to get to know my patients. What are
some of your interests? What do you like to do to relax?
Even if
youve met before, take a few minutes to break the ice. Ask the patient
about hobbies or family activities. Instead of questions that lead to a yes or
no answer, ask open-ended questions such as, Where have you traveled to
recently? or What have you been doing with your
grandchildren?
Dr. Lee takes this a step further and conducts the
full patient history himself. This gives him an opportunity to delve deeper
into patient needs. I actually save time by doing the history, he
says. There are important questions that might not occur to a tech. Also,
Im able to get the patient to open up about his or her general
well-being. Sometimes the patient doesnt tell you the main complaint
right away.
- Recognize cues. Studies of
physician-patient interviews show that doctors often ignore patients
nonverbal cues. Experts say that if you only respond to words, youll miss
opportunities to communicate better.
Eighty percent of important
social communication is nonverbal. You can tell when the patient is tuning you
out if he gets quiet, or his eyes glaze over. This may be because he
doesnt understand you, or because you arent addressing his
concerns, says Dr. Clark.
To get through to this patient, Mr.
Mauksch suggests you take the direct approach: Ask the patient, how well
am I understanding your concerns? Am I addressing your biggest
fears/difficulties?
Other important cues may be verbalized by the
patient, but ignored by the doctor, because they arent related to medical
facts. The patient might say their spouse is very upset. If the physician
ignores this, he or she is missing a chance to find out whats really
going on here. Maybe the spouses problem is the patients biggest
problem, explains Dr. Clark.
- Address patient concerns.
Physicians are trained to take charge of the situation, usually by creating an
agenda and then following it through. While this may be efficient, it can fall
short of addressing the patients true concerns.
Its
common for physicians to impose their agendas on patients instead of eliciting
a full list of patient concerns and expectations. They tend to exclude patients
from the decision-making, and create plans that patients may not be able or
willing to follow. Physicians usually do not pick up on patient clues about
important questions and fears because the physician is preoccupied with
attending to his or her own agenda, says Mr. Mauksch.
He offers
this alternate approach to encouraging patients to open up about
whats really concerning them:
Begin by asking what the
patient concerns and expectations are for the time.
Create
an agenda based on the patients concerns, and get the patients
agreement on the agenda.
Involve the patient in treatment
decision making.
Empathize with the patients situation,
pain, confusion, etc.
Inquire more about the patients
perspective on the illness to learn about personal, familial and cultural
beliefs and related treatment ideas.
- Reflect back what the patient
says. One of the best ways to be sure you understand what another person
says is to reflect back his or her words.
Especially in difficult
moments, it helps to reflect back what the patient said: So youre a
bit puzzled about what to do. Here, its best not to give more
medical facts, but to let the patient talk some more. You will gain more
information, and the patient will feel you are really listening, says Dr.
Clark.
You can use the same technique to be sure the patient
understands you. After you have given information or instructions, ask the
patient to repeat his or her understanding.
Have the patient
demonstrate comprehension by repeating what you said. The physician can ask:
Can you tell me the instructions we just went over to be sure I
didnt leave anything out? says Mr.
Platt.
- Speak in plain English.
Physicians tend to use medical terms, rather than simpler language that
patients understand. Be patient, speak clearly and sometimes louder.
Dont use jargon or medico speak, says Mr. Platt. Instead of
You have glaucoma and here is the medication, you might say,
You have too much pressure inside the eye and we need to give you a
medication that will lower this pressure.
Dr. Lee says a
valuable resource is patient information pamphlets, available from the American
Academy of Ophthalmology. Look through these to pick up phrases that will be
easy for patients to understand.
Its part of our job to be
teachers, he says. Doctors should read patient pamphlets and use
these terms instead of medical terms. Its wonderfully helpful, and
patients appreciate it.
Another way to educate patients and
answer their questions is to tell them what youre doing during the exam.
I give the patient a running commentary such as Now Im
testing your peripheral vision, says Dr. Lee. Then I give
feedback such as, I dont see any problems in the back of the
eye, or I dont see any changes from last time,
says Dr. Lee.
He notes that this process elicits questions from
patients that may lead to further information about their condition. Also, it
saves time when he describes the findings.
- Include the patients
companion. If your patient brings along a relative or caregiver, be sure to
include this person in your dialogue. Very often, this person is an important
resource for the patient when he or she leaves the office.
There
is always a reason that a patient is accompanied by someone else notes
Mr. Mauksch. While its important to not devalue the patients
autonomy, it is naive to ignore the influence that friends and family members
have. Moreover, caregivers are invaluable allies of physicians. Those present
in interviews who have caregiving responsibility may have their own set of
questions. He adds that even as you focus on the patient, you should be
alert for opportunities to care for the caregiver.
Caregivers need a lot of support, Mr. Mauksch says.
Not surprisingly, the risk of depression is much higher among family
caregivers supporting people with chronic illnesses than the general
population. So, ask the patient what the role of their companion is. And then
ask the companion what his concerns are. Sometimes you may discover a conflict
between patient and companion, which, if ignored, can complicate
care.
- Use backup media. Because there
is so much medical information, always use backup media to educate the patient
before the exam, or to reinforce what you said after the patient encounter is
over.
A picture is worth a thousand words. And a well-made video gives
consistent education. Besides, we are visual creatures, and studies have
shown increased retention when pictures and sound are used, says Mr.
Platt.
Dr. Lee gets additional mileage out of those patient pamphlets
available from the AAO. We always hand the appropriate brochure or
brochures to patients as they leave. Then they will have something to refer to,
and I know the same terminology is used as I already used in my
conversation, he says.
- Give enough time. Even though
most physicians are pressured to see more patients in less time, experts advise
you to use your best judgment when scheduling patients. Allowing enough time to
communicate well will enable you to be a better doctor, and will increase
patient satisfaction.
You cannot do this job without enough time
for each patient, warns Dr. Clark. You will stop being effective,
and you will burn out. He also notes that physicians who are interested
in improving their communication skills must devote time to this learning
processjust as they would for a new surgical technique or procedure.
This is like learning a new language, Dr. Clark says.
There is a certain grammar, syntax and use of words. Most physicians are
not beginners at communicating; they have many skills. But they should never
stop practicing to improve their skills.
Dr. Lee believes that
giving more time to each patient will lead to greater practice success, not
less. We have one of the busiest practices in Oakland. This is due to
word-of-mouth referral, one patient recommending us to another patient,
Dr. Lee says. He believes that ophthalmologists and all physicians today have a
tendency to underestimate the importance of what they do, and the value of
their communication with patients.
Because of the pressures of
modern health care, we tend to undervalue our worth to society, says Dr.
Lee. What we do is mundane to us, but not to our patients. Our worth is a
bit more than what you pay the plumber. We need to renew our pride in our
profession. What we do makes a real difference in peoples
lives.
SIDEBAR:
Why
Bedside Manner Matters
A number of research studies prove
that effective doctor-patient communication is extremely important. Heres
a quick review of the literature.
- Patient diagnosis is made 70
percent of the time from the patients history. (Patterson MC, et al:
Contributions of the history physical examination, and laboratory
investigation in making medical diagnosis, Western J Med. 1992
156:163-5.)
- Patients are more satisfied when
they feel all of their concerns have been addressed. (Stewart M, et al:
Patient Centered Interviewing, Part III: Five provocative
questions, Can Fam. Physicians 35:159-161,1989.)
- When patients are asked to
discuss their illness and its treatment immediately after leaving their
physicians office, they are able to correctly identify only about 50
percent of the critical information.(Cohen-Cole SA et al: Psychiatry for
internists: A study of needs, J Operational Psychiatry 1982; 13:100-105.)
- About 50 percent of patients do
not know what medications they are supposed to take (Hulka BS, et al:
Medication use and misuse: Physician-Patient discrepancies, J
Chronic Dis. 1975; 28:7-21.)
- Hundreds of studies indicate
that between 22 percent and 72 percent of patients do not follow their
doctors recommendations. (Sackett DL, Snow JC: The magnitude of
compliance and noncompliance, in Haynes R, Taylor D, Sackette DL (eds):
Compliance in Health Care. Baltimore, Johns Hopkins University Press, 1979.)
- Litigation is lower among
clinicians who have good communication skills. (Lester GW and Smith SG:
Listening and Talking to patients: A remedy for malpractice suits?
West. J. Med. 158:268-272,1993.)
- 71 percent of patients stated
poor relationships as a reason for their malpractice claims. (Levinson W:
Physician-patient communication. A key to malpractice
prevention JAMA 1994 Nov 23-30;272(20):1619-20 )
- Primary care physicians who had
never had a malpractice suit spent on average 3.3 minutes more with their
patients, and had a more patient-centered interviewing style. (Levinson W:
Physician-patient communication. A key to malpractice prevention,
JAMA 1994 Nov 23-30;272(20):1619-20 )
|
Other
Sources on Patient Communication
- www.PatientCommunications.com.
This website, developed by Neil Shulman, MD and Allan Platt, PA-C, is dedicated
to improving clinician-patient communication skills by providing tools, links
and information for educators and providers. The site offers monthly updates,
conference information, new products and a new differential diagnosis mnemonic
handbook and Palm Pilot Note file . Or, contact Allan Platt, PA-C, Patient
Communications Unlimited, 5830 Dovnick Drive, Lilburn, GA 30047. (770)
935-9710.
- www.bayerinstitute.com. The website
for the Bayer Institute for Health Care Communication, which is dedicated to
enhancing the quality of health care by improving the communication between the
clinician and the patient. The institute offers week-long sessions to improve
skills.
- The American Academy on
Physician and Patient, (703) 556-9222. President Barry Egener, MD,
503-276-6100, begener@lhs.org.
- The Macy Initiative in Health
Communications at New York University, Case Western Reserve University and the
University of Massachusetts. These schools are collaborating on a national
educational and training program to help improve physicians communication
skills and facilitate the doctor-patient relationship. The program will be
available to schools nationwide. Contact: Mack Lipkin Jr., MD, at NYU,
mack.lipkin@med.NYU.edu.
|
Return to
Features page
|